For want of a nail …

How much mercury does it take to kill a fish?   A quick search on Google reveals  just over 270000 hits for the search terms “mercury”, “toxicity” and “fish”, with one reputable-looking source close to the top of the list suggesting just under one part per million is all it takes to kill a rainbow trout within 24 hours.   Exposure to a lower concentration might also have the same effect, albeit over a longer period, and even very low concentrations might be enough to disrupt metabolism and impair breeding potential, or to kill delicate life stages such as fry.    Much more could be written about the effects of mercury but this is not, actually, my subject for this post.

We often find the term “parts per million” in discussions about harmful chemicals in the environment but what exactly does this mean?  How can we visualise what one part per million actually looks like?   Here are two examples:  one gram of rice consists of about 30 grains.  Now imagine being asked to look for three grains of rice in one bag of sugar.   A bag of sugar weighs a kilogramme, so this is equivalent to searching for one part in 10,000.   One part of rice per million would be searching for three grains of rice in 100 bags of sugar.   Alternatively, you could think of one part per million as the equivalent of emptying a “tall” Starbucks coffee into an Olympic-sized swimming pool (50 metres x 25 metres x 2 metres).

Metaphors and analogies such as these are useful means of conveying information about toxicity and risk but they introduce a further problem of making the quantities seem so infinitesimally small that they trivialise serious issues.   So let’s try two further analogies: first, a single screw may cost a few pennies and, therefore, be just one or two “parts per million” of the total cost of a car.  Yet, the absence of that screw might have serious implications for the performance of the car as a whole.   And a chilli con carné needs only a tiny amount of chilli powder to impart the spicy heat that characterises the dish.   However much meat and rice you serve, it is the tiny quantities of spices that define dishes such as this.

Many of the nutrients and minerals that sustain our ecosystems exist at concentrations well below one part per million in the natural world, sometimes as low as a few parts per billion (a thousand times smaller than “parts per million” – imagine a pinch of salt in ten tonnes of potato crisps).   Yet these, in turn, provide vital nuts and bolts in the machinery of life.   Toxic metals such as mercury interfere with these nuts and bolts without which the performance of whole organisms can shudder to a halt.

For want of a nail, the shoe was lost; for want of a shoe, the horse was lost, and so on ….

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s