Tales of Hofmann …


For the past five years or so the constant companion on my desk whilst I stare down my microscope has been a thick tome (2.8 kg) entitled Diatomeen im Süßwasser-Benthos von Mitteleuropa by Gabi Hofmann and colleagues.  It serves as my aide-mémoire when I am analysing freshwater diatoms, jogging my memory when I see a diatom that I recognise but whose name I have forgotten.  Before this was published, I used a French publication Guide Méthodologique pour la mise en oeuvre de l’Indice Biologique Diatomées which was free to download (I cannot find a link on the web any longer, unfortunately).   Neither of these is the last word in diatom taxonomy, but that was not the point: a lot of the time, I just need a gentle reminder of the right name for the species I am looking at, and I don’t want to have to pore through a pile of books in order to find this.

One of the strong points of both books is that they are copiously illustrated, and the plates are arranged very logically so that similar-shaped diatoms are together, making it easy to pick out differences.   For most routine identification, this is exactly what is needed: we may pretend that we are logical people but, in truth, pattern matching beats using a key nine times out of ten.   The 133 plates in Diatomeen im Süßwasser … act as a visual index and, to make life even easier, the species descriptions are arranged alphabetically and cross-referenced in the plates.  Having found an image that resembles the diatom I am trying to identify, it is straightforward to flick to the description to check the details.

There is just one problem: Diatomeen im Süßwasser-Benthos von Mitteleuropa is in German, and quite technical German at that.   I tell people not to worry because all the images are in English but, in truth, I worry that I may lose some of the nuances due to my linguistic limitations.   I was delighted, then, to be asked by Marco Cantonati to help produce an English version of the book.  Marco is half-German so reads and speaks the language fluently, and I was able to work on his first drafts in English to produce the final text.   Conscious that translating a German book into English is only a partial solution for the almost 70% of the EU who have neither as their first language, we also unpicked the prose in order to put the information about each species into a series of “bullet points” so that it was more accessible and we also took the opportunity to update some of the taxonomy.   A large part of last weekend was spent poring over the proofs so it should not be long now before it is available to purchase.

The great irony for me is that I am putting the finishing touches to this book at the same time as I am helping the Environment Agency to move away from using the light microscope to identify diatoms altogether.   I am just finalising the last of the regular competency tests that I organise in which, Environment Agency staff will participate, after which routine samples will be sent off for Next Generation Sequencing rather than being analysed by light microscope.  I’ve written about the pros and cons of this before (see “Primed for the unexpected …”) but there is a funny side.   After over a decade of struggling with identification literature in a language that almost none of them spoke my dedicated band of Environment Agency analysts get the book they dreamed about two months after their last diatom slide is packed away.   My sense of timing is, as ever, impeccable …

Hofmann, G., Werum, M. & Lange-Bertalot, H. (2011).   Diatomeen im Süßwasser-Benthos von Mitteleuropa. A.R.G. Gantner Verlag K.G., Rugell.

Prygiel, J.  & Coste, M. (2000).   Guide Méthodologique pour la mise en oeuvre de l’Indice Biologique Diatomées.   NF T 90-354.  Cemagref, Bordeaux.


Tidings of Great Joy …


About three years ago I was one of a small group of people who met in the bowels of the National Museum of Wales in Cardiff to discuss the options for producing an online guide to the freshwater diatoms of Britain and Europe.   There were, we reasoned, good guides to most of the rest of the algae found on these islands, and plenty of guides to the diatoms of continental Europe.  There was also an active community of people interested in diatoms for a variety of reasons, both professional and recreational.   There had also been well-intentioned initiatives in the past, the most recent of which was a CD-ROM that I helped to produce for the Environment Agency a few years ago.  I wrote about that sorry saga in “The decline and fall of a CD-ROM”.

There are good reasons why it has not been possible to produce a good guide to diatoms in the past, not least of which has been the shifting sands of diatom taxonomy, which creates instability for anyone who is trying to collate information on the present state of play or, for that matter, to put names on the myriad forms of diatoms that one sees when peering down a microscope.   A more practical reason, over the last few years, has been the absence of anyone with the time and resources to mastermind a project but that situation was about to change, thanks to the National Museum of Wales, who gave their diatom curator Ingrid Jüttner time to work on the project.   They also had experience of developing online taxonomic aids, and a basic “shell” for a website that could be adapted to our needs.   The missing link was funding to allow others with practical or academic interests in diatom taxonomy to travel and meet up to support the project.  That problem was solved thanks to generous support from the British Phycological Society.


The homepage for the genus Nitzschia in the Diatom Flora of Britain and Ireland.

And so, today, the Freshwater Diatom Flora of Britain and Ireland was launched on the National Museum of Wales website and I encourage you all to have a look.   Comparing the swish tablet-friendly website to our CD-ROM is a salutary experience.   That had to be run from a computer with a CD-ROM drive, which meant that either your microscope had to be close to your desktop or you had a laptop or you were constantly dashing across the laboratory to compare the image on the screen with the specimen under your microscope.  There was, at the time, an edict within the Environment Agency that prohibited desktop computers from laboratories, which further complicated the issue.  Now you can check specimens on an iPad as easily as consult a paper flora.  And that is quite important because, in my experience, there are three levels of biological identification.  First, there is a basic pool of species that you can name from memory, then there are rare and difficult specimens that cannot be identified easily and which require you to consult the literature.   Finally, there is a group of species that fall between these two categories that you recognise but for which you may need a “nudge” to match them to the right name.   For these, an aide mémoire that you can consult easily is invaluable.  I always felt that the Lucid software that drove the CD-ROM was a little too clunky to serve this purpose, but a website accessible via a tablet might approach the functionality of my paper-based identification aids.

The diatom flora has images and descriptions of most freshwater genera, and of the most commonly encountered species.  But there is still a long way to go.   The next couple of years will see us start filling in some of the gaps in order to improve coverage, both in the number of species and the amount of information about each.   At the moment, the focus is on valve morphology, but there is more that could be written about live diatoms and about their ecology, for a start.  But we have made the first steps and, importantly for this modern age, we have burst the old paradigm that regards taxonomic literature as stolid inflexible overviews of the state of the art at a point in time, and emerged blinking into a new era where the medium is flexible enough to accommodate change and evolve as our understanding improves.


The webpage for Nitzschia dissipata in the Diatom Flora of Britain and Ireland, with the description on the left and images on the right.

The decline and fall of a CD-ROM

I’ve just looked back at a paper I wrote for a symposium in 2004. It described a CD-ROM I was helping to develop at the time for the UK’s Environment Agency, to help their analysts to identify diatoms.   The tone of the article is upbeat and positive, eulogising the potential for interactive CD-ROMs for identification.

So much for that.   The Environment Agency has just deleted our key from their publications catalogue.   In so doing they fulfil one of the prophecies in my paper.   The software, quite simply, evolved faster than we were able to respond.   We had a bold vision for a modular project, developing from a first release with about 300 common diatoms found in rivers into, eventually, comprehensive coverage of all diatoms found in Britain and Ireland. We had recognised, too, that the software would have to evolve to keep track of other developments in hardware and software. However, within about a year of the release of the CD-ROM, the Environment Agency’s priorities shifted and (more significantly) funding became much tighter.   Funding for the additional modules never happened.   More importantly, there have been changes in the licensing agreement for the software that we used to develop the key which means that our package would need to be modified if it were to be sold as a user-friendly entity again.   The publications team at the Environment Agency did not consult us before deleting the CD-ROM but, even if they had done, I doubt that there would have been funding available to cover the time needed to upgrade the package.

This saga illustrates some of the pitfalls of using new media. I have, on my bookshelf, a facsimile edition of Frederich Hustedt’s flora of freshwater diatoms from central Europe, first published in 1930. Many of the taxonomic ideas are now out of date but the illustrations and descriptions are still useful, 86 years after firs publication. By contrast, our CD-ROM was obsolete within a decade.   The whole idea of a CD-ROM, indeed, sounds rather quaint in 2014 and, to emphasise the point, I am typing this post on a laptop which does not have a CD-ROM drive.   The latest versions of the Lucid software are aimed at online keys and the prospect of using an iPad or even a mobile phone as a platform for identifying organisms is tantalising (and ,indeed, already possible for some groups: see the Field Studies Council publication website).

The same issues about upgrading and maintenance will apply as much to a website as to a CD-ROM. As soon as I stop paying my subscription, my own websites will disappear, along with all the information stored on them.   Large institutions such as the Environment Agency and national museums ought to be more resilient but I fear that it would only take a small shift in an organisation’s priorities or a change in key personnel for an active website to become fossilised or archived.

The good news is that all of the information except the keys themselves are available on the web, courtesy of Steve Juggin’s website at Newcastle University and that there are plans to develop a new online diatom flora of Britain and Ireland, hosted by the National Museum of Wales.  And, of course, if all these fail, I will still have my trusty copy of Hustedt’s Flora.


One aspect of the CD-ROM that will not be missed: the grim cover of the CD-ROM. Not a single diatom in sight.


Kelly, M.G., Bennion, H., Cox, E.J., Goldsmith, B., Jamieson, B.J., Juggins, S., Mann, D.G. & Telford, R.J. (2006). An interactive CD-ROM for identifying freshwater diatoms. pp. 153-161. Proceedings of the 18th International Diatom Symposium (edited by A. Witkowski). Biopress, Bristol.