An excuse for a crab sandwich, really …

My curiosity about the habits of Navicula bottnica led me to the fishing village of Staithes, on the North Yorkshire coast, at the weekend, in search of a sample from the location I visited in 2012 (see “More diatoms that like cold weather …”).   Staithes, the birthplace of local hero, Captain Cook, also has the added attraction of a pub in the harbour that sells wonderful crab sandwiches.

Staithes_March2015

Staithes: left, a view of the village from the south and, right, sampling Staithes Beck.

I collected my samples in 2012 from a set of stepping stones across Staithes Beck, which flows through the village.   At low tide, the stream here is virtually freshwater, but the diatoms that live on the stones have to be adapted to higher salinities when the tide is high.   Even through the brown films looked identical to those that I see in rivers far from the sea (see “The ecology of cold days”), many of the diatoms are different.   I did, however, see a number of cells of Navicula gregaria gliding around.   The most abundant diatom was, however, larger than these and a subtly different shape to Navicula lanceolata, which tends to dominate these habitats in freshwaters. At very high magnification, I could just make out the dense radiate striae that characterise N. bottnica.

But no mucilage tubes.   The Navicula cells were gliding around unencumbered by any such superstructures.   They clearly have not read the literature: Andrej Witkowski’s Diatom Flora of Marine Coasts describes it as “probably cosmopolitan” (another way of saying “I don’t know where it isn’t found”), then “… tube dwelling species distributed along the coasts of the cooler seas of the northern hemisphere, more common in the brackish waters of the Baltic Sea.”   I do often find diatoms that are described as “tube dwelling” that are free-living. I suspect that this is because I mostly look at habitats where a tube would be an impediment rather than an advantage. On these submerged stones, for example, I suspect that being able to constantly adjust their position relative to the light is more important than the benefits conferred by the relatively-static tube.   On the other hand, Eileen Cox noted that tube-dwelling diatoms preferred hard to soft substrata in the Severn Estuary.

Navicula_bottnica_Staithes_2015

Navicula cf bottnica collected from upper surfaces of stones in the tidal section of Staithes Beck, Staithes, North Yorkshire, March 2015. The right hand view is a girdle view of a recently divided cell.   Scale bar: 10 micrometres (=1/100th of a millimetre).

In case you have not seen a tube-dwelling diatom before, I have included a couple of Chris Carter’s photos of Encyonema (caespitosum?).   The ability to form tubes seems to have evolved in several genera, although not necessarily in all representatives of a genus and not necessarily all the time. I have written about the tube-dwelling diatom Berkeleya rutilans (see “Diatoms from Pangong Tso”) and tubes are also common in the genus Frustulia as well as in several marine and intertidal genera.

Why produce tubes?   I have never read any detailed accounts of the pros and cons of tube-formation, though I imagine that the mucilage must offer some protection against desiccation, high light and grazers and I have also heard speculation that the mucilage might act as a substrate for some extracellular enzymes.   As I have grumbled before, diatomists are generally more interested in the minutiae of the silica frustule than the Meaning of Life.

Encyonema_tubes_ChrisCarter

Two photos of Encyonema (caespitosum?) growing in mucilage tubes.   Both by Chris Carter.

References

Cox, E.J. (1977). The distribution of tube-dwelling diatom species in the Severn Estuary.   Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the UK 57: 19-27.

Witkowski A. (2000). Diatom Flora of Marine Coasts I.   Iconographica Diatomologica: Annotated Diatom Monographs (edited by H. Lange-Bertalot).   Koeltz Scientific Books, Koenigstein.

Advertisements

More diatoms that like cold weather …

One of the benefits of studying diatoms is that we can produce permanent slides from our samples, which means that we can go back at any time to have another look at samples we collected in the past.   As I was writing my previous post, I recalled some other brown films that I had seen in a tidal section of a river and it did not take long to find the slide and put it under my microscope again.

The sample comes from Staithes Beck, a short stream that flows into the North Sea at the old fishing village of Staithes, on the edge of the North York Moors in Yorkshire.   I had visited this stream in February 2012 as part of a project and had wondered about the composition of the films. I did not have time to look at them in their fresh state but, instead, viewed them a month or so later when the slides were prepared. Some of the diatoms that I wrote about in The Ecology of Cold Days were here, obviously able to cope with the more saline conditions less than a kilometre from the mouth of the stream.   However, the most abundant diatom was a species that I had never encountered in freshwaters: Navicula bottnica.   It has the same symmetrical boat-shaped outline as Navicula lanceolata but the arrangement of the striae – the lines on the frustule – were very different. In N. bottnica these were both denser and much more strongly radiate, especially towards the centre.   On the other hand, apart from the difference in salinity, it seemed to have a very similar habitat – forming distinctive brown films on the tops of submerged stones in fast-flowing sections of the river in the winter and early Spring.

I did find one reference on the internet to Navicula bottnica living in mucilage-tubes, which is intriguing and makes me wish that I had checked this myself in the Staithes community.   I have found that most of the species described as living in tubes are also often found free-living too. The study that recorded N. bottnica in tubes was on the physiology of diatoms in intertidal zones on rocky shores whereas my communities in Staithes Beck were permanently submerged. I suspect that a rocky shore presents a rather more severe challenge to diatoms, with periodic exposure to the air and higher levels of radiation. This would mean that a form of extracellular protection would confer some protection to the diatoms that, perhaps, is not needed in a permanently submerged community.

Navicula_bottnica_Staithes

Navicula bottnica from Staithes Beck, Staithes, February 2012.

Reference

Ginnever, N.E. (2014). The photophysiology of rocky intertidal microphytobenthic biofilms.   PhD thesis, University of Cardiff, Cardiff.