The Clear Mirror

clear_mirror

My microscopical investigations of Pangong Tsu a couple of weeks ago (see “Diatoms from the Roof of the World”) set me of on a hunt for an intriguing book.   In this post I mentioned that the eminent British-born limnologist G. Evelyn Hutchinson had visited the lake in the 1930s as part of the Yale North India Expedition. In addition to the scientific outputs from this expedition, he also wrote a travel book, The Clear Mirror. It is now out of print but I managed to track down a secondhand copy from a German book dealer via Abebooks.   It is an intriguing book, divided into three parts: a preliminary account of the art and architecture of catholic churches and institutions in the then Portuguese enclave of Goa, followed by a description of Buddhist monuments and ceremonies in and around Leh. Finally, he moves on from Leh to Pangong Tsu and surrounding lakes, and gives an interesting description of the ecology of the lake and of the vegetation of the surrounding areas.

The book captures Hutchinson’s extraordinary breadth of interest. The prose style is, to be frank, somewhat dated and my version had no illustrations to liven the experience, but I could not but be impressed by a writer who is prepared to tackle the art and symbolism of two different religions and the ecology of terrestrial and aquatic habitats in a single book. It is not the first time I have stumbled on Hutchinson during my travels: whilst working on the vegetation history of peninsula Italy during the late 1980s, I stumbled across a volume he had edited on the history of Lago di Monterosi , a small lake just north of Rome. Once again, the work managed to juxtapose ecology with disciplines as diverse as archaeology and classics.

Hutchinson’s breadth of interest did not come at the expense of depth in his own specialist research, because he was a very notable limnologist in his own right, the author of a very significant textbook, A Treatise on Limnology, and responsible for many significant advances, not least both proposing and partially resolving the paradox of the plankton (explaining the great diversity of plankton species in the face of the competitive exclusion principle).   They don’t make them like him any more.

Reference

Hutchinson, G.E. (1970). Ianula: an account of the history and development of Lago di Monterosi, Latium, Italy. Transactions of the American Philosophical Society 60: 1-178.

Advertisements

Diatoms from the roof of the world

Whilst I was enjoying myself in Venice and the Dolomites, most of my family were hard at work earning an honest crust or studying. One, however, was looking at mountains considerably higher than anything that Europe has to offer.   As she was, technically, reconnoitring locations for a study visit to Kashmir and Ladakh next summer she will tell us that it was work rather than holiday, but we should treat this claim with a generous pinch of salt.

Pangong_Tsu

Pangong Tsu, looking east towards the distant mountains of Tibet.   September 2014 (photo: H. Kelly)

One souvenir of her visit was a small sample of algae from the littoral zone of the remote Pangong Tsu at an altitude of 4266 metres on the Indian-Tibetan border.   Problem #1 for anyone working in such locations is how to preserve samples for the journey home. There is a simple solution: buy a bottle of cheap local vodka.   My limited experience of Indian spirits is that using them to preserve algae is a better option than drinking them and, in any case, the high altitude of Ladakh will give the partially-acclimated traveller a cracking headache without any need for chemical assistance. The downside is that the cell contents are not preserved very well but as diatomists are mostly interested in the silica cell wall this is not a problem.

Pangong_periphyton

A view of the periphyton from the littoral zone of Pangong Tsu (approx.. 33° 45’ N, 78° 38’ E), photographed at 400x magnification.

A first look at the sample down my microscope revealed a number of diatoms that looked broadly familiar though which differ in detail from species with which I am familiar with in Europe.   There were, for example, a lot of cells of Gomphonema, each at the end of a long stalk, though these were not a species that I recognised.   Within this tangle of stalks, I could see a number of zig-zag chains of a species of Diatoma but, again, it was not a form I had seen in Europe.   There were other taxa, too, but I will wait until I have cleaned the material and prepared a permanent slide before commenting further.

pangong_gomphonema

Gomphonema cells from the littoral zone of Pangong Tsu, September 2014. The four cells on the left are in valve view; the two on the right are in girdle view.   The stalk is visible on the right hand image. Scale bar: 10 micrometres (= 1/100th of a millimetre).

pangong_diatoma

Cells of Diatoma from the littoral zone of Pangong Tsu, September 2014.   The lefthand image is in valve view; the central and right hand images are in girdle view.   The central image shows a cell that has recently divided.   The cells are joined at the corners to form zig-zag colonies. Scale bar: 10 micrometres (= 1/100th of a millimetre).

There seems to be very little published on Pangong Tsu, as befits its remote location.   One early visitor was the famous limnologist G. Evelyn Hutchinson, as part of the Yale North India Expedition in the early 1930s.   The papers that I did find told me that the water of Pangong Tsu is slightly brackish, as the lake has no outlets and water is lost by evaporation. However, I usually associate Gomphonema with freshwater habitats, suggesting that the brackish influence is very weak. There is also evidence of very high concentrations of phosphorus in the lake, although nitrogen concentrations are very low. This suggests that growth of the organisms in the lake may be limited by nitrogen rather than phosphorus, as is usually the case in lakes.   I would be interested to know why a lake that is so remote contains phosphorus concentrations that are usually associated with human activity.

The next step is to make some permanent slides from the material and have another look, then see if any of the diatoms in this sample correspond to species found elsewhere in the region or beyond. There is a chance, based on the lake’s isolation and recent discoveries that the diversity of diatoms was much greater than hitherto thought, that there may be some previously undescribed species living in this unusual habitat.

References

Bhat, F.A., Yousuf, A.R., Aftab, A., Arshid, J., Mahdi, M.D. & Balkhi, M.H. (2011). Ecology and biodiversity in Pangong Tsu (lake) and its inlet stream in Ladakh, India. International Journal of Biodiversity and Conservation 3: 501-511.

Hutchinson, G.E. (1933). Limnological studies at high altitudes in Ladakh. Nature (London) ##: 132-136.

Hutchinson, G.E. (1937). Limnological studies in Indian Tibet.   Int. Hydrobiol. 35: 134-177.